Tuesday, December 20, 2016

A Century of Liberal Failure


Have you noticed how bitter liberals are at their electoral defeat?  They not only expected to win; they felt entitled to do so.  They have, as a result, been the sorest of sore losers.  As this is being written, they are plotting ways to make sure Donald Trump does not enjoy the traditional presidential honeymoon.
Across the nation, Trump is being attacked as a fascist and terrorist.  His victory is described as illegitimate; hence rioters felt free to vent their spleens.  Meanwhile, calls for his assassination have been heard, members of the Electoral College urged to break their faith, and voter recounts pursued.
Can you recall any post-election this vituperative?  When have Republicans acted this spitefully?  Both of the Bushes left office gracefully.  Their supporters were disappointed, but they resigned themselves to defeat.  Gerald Ford and his allies were also good losers.  They had doubts about Jimmy Carter, but were not about to destroy the nation on this account.
Nor can I remember a precedent for Barack Obama’s behavior.  He has gone on what amounts to an “I was really a great President” tour.  Both at home and abroad, he elucidated, in mendacious detail, why he was not responsible for his party’s loss and urged the new chief executive to continue his policies.
Obama has been known for taking undeserved victory laps.  Now he assures us that his personal popularity is proof his two terms in office were triumphs.  According to him, he saved us from a depression and single-handedly rescued America’s international reputation.
But contemplate how much worse off we actually are.  ObamaCare is in a death spiral.  ISIS terrorism remains with us.  The Iran deal gave an implacable foe cover for terrorism and the right to acquire nuclear weapons.  As for the economy, it has never grown at more than 2 percent.
Nonetheless, this is par for the course for liberal administrations.  On their watch educational achievement has plummeted, crime rates have risen, and the welfare roles have swollen.  Despite their big promises about equality and justice, these were never kept.
Nor is this a recent development.   Liberalism can lay claim to a century of failure.  Virtually everything progressives have touched has turned to dross.  Lest we forget, it was Woodrow Wilson who brought segregation to our nation’s capital, Franklin Roosevelt who lengthened the Great Depression, Lyndon Johnson who lost the War on Poverty, and Jimmy Carter who gave us the Great Inflation.
If asked about their achievements, liberals generally cite Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.  But even these are in actuarial trouble.  What is more, Democratic attainments in civil rights owe as much to Republicans as themselves.  After all, it was the Dixiecrats who opposed voting legislation and Nixon who introduced affirmative action.
Why then are liberals so sour?  Why have they gone ballistic over their current defeat?  They have had setbacks before and recovered.  Nor is it because Trump has egregiously misbehaved.  If anything, his cabinet choices demonstrate a sincere intention to reinstate conservative principles.
Nonetheless, this is the problem.  If Trump is successful, it might finally dawn on voters that neo-socialist promises are a fraud.  Blacks and Hispanics might realize that conservative policies, if given a chance, would leave them better off.  So might the blue collar workers at the historic heart of the Democratic coalition.
With Obama in office and the mainstream media guarding his flanks, liberals were able to disguise the depth of their failures.  They were able to claim that no one could have done better in protecting our economy and national security.
What will they do if these hyperbolic pretensions are exposed?  Already people have grown tired of identity politics and political correctness.  Ordinary Americans are fatigued by the lies and angered by the perpetual unfairness.  Many long for a return to the old verities.
If Trump delivers on these, liberalism might conclusively be discredited.  Implementation of an American Dream that actually provides opportunity, liberty, and integrity may, in fact, reduce the prevailing cynicism.  If so, neo-Marxism could go into a fatal decline.  No wonder progressives are worried.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology

Kennesaw State University

No comments:

Post a Comment