Saturday, April 28, 2012

The Right to Disrupt



As you might imagine, I do not usually hang around with the Occupy Wall Street crowd. But last week I made an exception. At the request of a student, I attended a panel at KSU’s Suburban Conference on social issues. He wanted me to serve as a counter-weight to what he knew would be an ideologically skewed presentation.

Subsequently, for more than an hour I sat quietly, if not patiently, as a series of activists celebrated their adventures in disruptive behavior. They boasted about how they entered parks with permits, then refused to leave. They likewise gloated about how they “saved” people from eviction by physically interceding on their behalf.

What rankled the most, however, was the glee in their eyes as they described how they shut down foreclosure auctions by singing as loudly as they could. As one of the presenters put it, “It was a beautiful thing.”

Shortly after this, I could contain myself no longer. Consequently, I raised my hand to assert, rather energetically, that this was one of the most “ignorant” and shortsighted displays I had witnessed in recent memory.

Naturally, this was not perceived as constructive criticism. Quiet the contrary, my use of the word ignorant was decried as an unprofessional epithet. Nonetheless, the accuracy of this descriptor was shortly confirmed by the reaction to another of my comments.

In trying to explain why the Occupy tactics would make things worse, I alluded to the Great Depression as a cautionary precedent. To this the reply was that precedents did not matter; that they were irrelevant.

When I further inquired about whether I got my facts wrong, I was told that the current situation was unique and therefore what happened in the past need not be considered. Indeed, it was plain that at least one of the presenters had no knowledge about the financial policies of the Roosevelt administration, nor of their impact.

But what really set the fur to flying was when I asserted that the Occupy people were not protesters, but provocateurs. This was not appreciated. The presenters did not perceive interfering with what others were lawfully doing as a provocation. They were merely seeking much needed publicity for a good cause.

From their point of view, I was the provocateur. It was I who was interfering with their ability to make their case. Meanwhile, it was their duty to be as unruly as the situation merited. After all, they were only protecting the rights of others.

Obviously, people had a “right” to housing—irrespective of whether they could afford it. They also had a “right” not to pay back their loans. It was the banks that were at fault. It was they that forced people to take out loans they could not afford and therefore they that should bear the burden of the defaults.

When an older, more experienced member of the audience objected that buyers had a responsibility to take on obligations they could manage, this was airily dismissed. Nor did the presenters acknowledge that shutting down the nation’s financial system would have dire economic consequences.

Smug and self-satisfied, they directed their ire toward me. Amazingly these activists who prided themselves on their lack of public civility lectured me on the need to be civil. They were merely making an intellectual case, whereas I was violating the canons of academic etiquette by being vociferous in my objections.

Indeed, they complained about my behavior to the conference organizers. Even though they identified themselves as dissenters, they were not prepared to tolerate dissent directed their way.

They were especially unhappy that my critique was so voluble. While they routinely shout down others, they demanded rights they deny their adversaries. Clearly, their idea of fairness is rather one-sided. Evidently, they reside on a more rarified moral plane than ordinary mortals.

Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.

Professor of Sociology

Kennesaw State University

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Social Discipline

We have become a middle class society, but in the process we have inadvertently corrupted our lower classes. Because the rules that apply to middle class folks don’t always apply to the poor, treating everyone the same has resulted in a host of tragedies. Let me explain. I have been reading Charles Murray’s new book “Coming Apart” as well as an article about Melvin Kohn’s ideas on social values, and putting the pieces together. What they suggest is something that at first blush sounds antithetic to the American Dream. Murray richly documents the diverging fates of those at the upper and lower ends of our social class system. While members of the upper middle class are doing very nicely, the lowest thirty percent are trapped in a cycle of crime, unemployment, and disintegrating marriages. Moreover, they are unhappy. Meanwhile, Kohn has provided evidence that middle class parents teach their children to be self-directed, whereas lower class parents demand conformity. The latter insist on obedience and if it is not forthcoming have no compunctions about imposing physical discipline. What this results in are upper middle class children who are capable of self-discipline and lower class children who have difficulty with self-control. The former internalize social standards such as morality, while the latter become oppositional and seek to get away with what they can. The difference in these orientations is on display in the sports they favor. Thus, the middle classes enjoy golf, an activity that is notorious for the personal concentration it requires. The lower classes, however, are enraptured by pro-wrestling, a spectacle in which large-bodied paladins often cheat in order to defeat their opponents. This disparity may seem amusing, yet is anything but. When it is translated onto the larger social scene, it means that middle class persons are more worthy of trust than their lower class peers. Because they monitor their own behaviors and control their selfish impulses, they can be allowed to function without external controls. Indeed, as social leaders they often control others. Meanwhile, those belonging to the lower strata more often seek to elude social constraints. They hate being bound by rules, thus if they believe their activities are not being monitored, they over-step the lines. I saw this when I worked at a methadone clinic where the attitude was that lawbreaking was okay—as long as you didn’t get caught. Put this together with the fact that our society today believes in “tolerance” and the consequences are alarming. We are now supposed to offer everyone “unconditional positive regard” and refrain from being “judgmental.” This stance appears humane, yet is fraught with danger. We can indeed take a hands-off approach with people who are self-directed. Because they discipline themselves, they can be allowed to make independent choices. On the other hand, those who are not self-directed cannot be extended a similar independence. In short, members of the lower classes require a greater variety of external constraints. If they are to behave in a disciplined manner, they must be subject to exterior sanctions when they violate social standards. Nonetheless, we as a society have decided that imposing standards on people violates their rights. This tactic, while it works perfectly well with most middle class folks, invites irresponsibility and lethargy from lower class folks. Once upon a time, most people understood this. They realized that social discipline was required if we were to have an orderly society. The founding fathers recognized this when they endorsed religion as a means of keeping people socially accountable. Most ordinary people endorsed it when they subscribed to a legal system that punished the guilty. They also approved it when they scorned those who broke their marriage vows. Regretfully, we too must uphold social discipline. The fact is that there are some folks who need it and others who suffer when it is absent. Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D. Professor of Sociology Kennesaw State University

Saturday, April 14, 2012

Unmitigated Arrogance

It was the Fall of 1944. The American army had broken out of Normandy and was hurtling toward the German border. Far to the east the Soviet juggernaut was poised to smash its way into Berlin. Nonetheless, Adolf Hitler remained confident. Whatever the appearances, Nazism would find a way to prevail.
Certain that he was on the side of history, Hitler ordered his forces to stand their ground. They were not to retreat an inch. But if they did; if they did not hurl back the foe, the German people deserved to lose. If they refused to keep their faith with the fuehrer, then they ought to be punished for their moral and physical weakness.
When I began to contemplate this column, I thought I would be writing about Newt Gingrich. His assumption that providence owed him the presidential nomination struck me as inordinately vain. He was not an Adolf Hitler, but his attitude too seemed destructively arrogant.
Yet Newt has tempered his anger at Mitt Romney. He still talks of taking his crusade to the floor of the Republican convention, yet his heart does not seem to be in it.
Meanwhile, Rick Santorum has emerged as a political monomaniac. He is so certain that he enjoys the mandate of heaven that it often seems he does not care what happens to the nation if his campaign falters. In perceiving himself as the true, and only, salvation for what ails America, it sounds as if he is prepared to pull down the temple if he does not get his way.
The sage heads in the Republican Party are now telling Santorum that continuing the fight will injure the likely candidate and make it probable that Obama will be re-elected. But Rick is not moved. He has persuaded himself that he can still win despite the odds. All he has to do is stand his ground and not retreat an inch.
Members of the media have frequently portrayed Santorum as a zealot. They make him sound like a true believer who is ready to do anything for his cause. Now he seems determined to prove his critics right. In his myopic rigidity, he has taken to distorting reality almost as much as the Nazi’s once did.
Take Rick’s repeated mantras over the last few months. For one thing, he regularly denounces Romney for running a negative campaign. Nonetheless, it is Santorum who has been relentlessly negative. Romney keeps trying to shift the focus onto president Obama’s faults, but he has been forced to ward off attacks from his fellow Republican instead.
Consider the piece of sophistry about how Romney cannot stand up against ObamaCare because RomneyCare is so similar. First, there are important differences between these plans that Santorum blatantly ignores. But more importantly, Obama cannot attack Ronmey’s position, without having to defend his own. And since he cannot do this, Mitt can easily rock him back on his heels.
Then there is the Santorum canard that a floor fight in Tampa will not damage the Republican Party or its candidate. Can anyone seriously believe this? With charges and counter-charges regarding the mendacity and incompetence potential contenders being tossed around like live grenades, is it possible to believe that none of these will go off?
Rick Santorum has proved that he had a lot to say during the past several months. Moreover, he has clearly given us food for thought. But the time for debating the issues is over. The current objective is not to score points; it is to win an election.
If Santorum does not understand this, he is not fit to be president. If he does not care and in the process bequeaths us a second Obama term, he is a rapscallion who is concerned more about his own interests than those of others.
Indeed, if it is the latter, he needs to realize he is digging his political grave.
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University

Sunday, April 8, 2012

The Niceness Trap

For liberals, niceness is an article of faith. They believe that in the best of all possible worlds everyone will be nice to everyone else. Nonetheless, too much niceness can have alarming consequences.
Many of these downsides have been documented in Charles Murray’s new book “Coming Apart.” He makes it plain that millions of poor people have suffered irreparable damage as a result of being treated with a super-abundance of sweetness and light.
Liberals are fond of chiding conservatives for “blaming the victim.” They tell us that backward looking people are too ready to hold the poor responsible to problems they did not create. If these unenlightened troglodytes will only back off and treat those injured by capitalistic excess with respect, these downtrodden souls will be able to overcome their disabilities.
Murray, however, demonstrates just how severe is the plight of the lower classes. On almost every measure, the top twenty percent in our society are doing far better than the lowest thirty percent.
Let us consider marriage. Everyone knows that divorce rates have risen precipitously. Yet many do not realize that middle class couples tend to stay married, whereas poor couples do not. Indeed, the poor have a distressing habit of not marrying at all. They merely cohabit until convenience—or a jail sentence—cleaves them asunder.
This might not seem an insuperable problem, except for the fact that these folks often have babies. They do not wait to tie the knot before they start producing the next generation. Sadly, many procreate even before leaving their teens.
Given that two out of every five children are today born out of wedlock and that their parents are liable to be dirt poor, the impact of non-committed sex can be drastic. Since the children of unmarried parents are likely to grow up poor, uneducated, and unhappy, this means that millions of children are condemned to misery thanks to the unrestrained impulses of their parents.
But liberals tell us that we must be nice. We ought not condemn a disadvantaged teenage girl for having unprotected sex with a guy who is unemployed and strung out on drugs. It is not her fault that life dealt her a faulty hand. After all, she is doing the best she can to survive.
According to them, it makes sense that a woman with meager marital prospects might desire motherhood to compensate for her unhappy fate? Why indeed shouldn’t she seize the few pleasures available to her?
The answer, of course, is that her choices affect others. More specifically, they have dire consequences for her offspring. It may be a cliché to say they did not ask to be born, but they did not. Nor did they ask to be born to irresponsible parents.
Once upon a time we called children conceived under these circumstances “bastards.” By the same token, we condemned their mothers as the next best thing to prostitutes. These women were not treated kindly, hence they and their families sought to hide their shame.
But as the targets of humiliation, they did something else. Even though they were poor, they sought to avoid illegitimacy. Then, if a mistake were made, they rectified it with shotgun alliances.
Beyond this, many of the poor avoided illicit pregnancies because they feared the wrath of the church. Routinely told that they would go to Hell for their transgressions, they controlled their wayward urges. Unfortunately, as Murray has also documented, the poor are no longer going to church in large numbers. Who then is to hold them accountable for their actions?
The poor may not be responsible for having caused their dilemma. But they are responsible for many of the behaviors that perpetuate it. This being so, is it really nice to let them off the hook without a word of disapproval?
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University

Saturday, March 31, 2012

Who is College For?

Rick Santorum does not believe that college is for everyone. Apparently neither does Barack Obama. Both agree that some folks are better off with a technical education. But whom does that leave college for?
Let’s agree that it is not exclusively for “snobs.” We are nearing twenty-five thousand students at Kennesaw State University and very few of them fit this appellation. Let’s also agree that college has become too expensive. Certainly the upwards of fifty thousand dollars that some elite universities charge is too rich for most pocketbooks.
Let’s also agree that not everyone has the ability to pursue a higher education. Not only do some people hate academics, but a great many of them do not have the candlepower to deal with the subject matter in which traditional universities specialize.
That still leaves the question as to who can benefit from four or more years of college. Many nowadays think in terms of acquiring marketable skills. They (or their parents) decide that it is worth the effort because they will then qualify for jobs that enable them to earn an additional million dollars over the course of a lifetime.
First of all, let’s understand that not everyone benefits from this monetary bonus. The higher the percentage of the population obtaining a degree, the smaller is the financial differential between college and high school. After all, not everyone is going to become a high-power executive just because they take extra years of schooling.
Nor is every major going to have an equal payoff. If you want to be an accountant, college is pretty much the best place to acquire the requisite skills. But if you major in communications—as many nowadays do—the odds of becoming an on-screen television reporter are slim.
So let me switch gears. Let me share a personal experience. Far too many years ago, when I was an undergraduate, I took a course in anthropology. I’m not sure why I did—I was not an anthropology major—but it turned out to be an eye-opening experience.
One of the books we were required to read was about the Tiwi. Who, you may ask, are the Tiwi? They are an obscure aboriginal tribe living on Melville Island just off the north coast of Australia. Although not particularly important; they made a huge impression on me.
Consider that this is many decades later and I still remember them. I recollect how they went to war by symbolically trying to wound the enemy rather than kill him. I also recall how the older men married much younger women, who nonetheless cheated on them with the younger men by having liaisons in the bush.
Why does this matter? Well, on a certain level, it doesn’t. Ignorance of the Tiwi’s is not going to make or break many careers. Nevertheless, for me, my introduction to them was life changing. It shook me out of a complacency born of an absent-minded ethnocentrism.
Like most people I grew up believing that the world surrounding me was the norm. A majority of Georgians would not agree that the gritty streets of south Brooklyn exemplify the way ordinary people live, but they did for me. It took a college course in anthropology to make me realize that there were alternative ways of living.
Which brings me back to the question of what is college for? My answer is that for many it is preparation to become social leaders. It changes their frame of reference so that they can deal life’s complexities better than they would have had they remained parochial in their outlook.
Universities are not merely about honing technical skills. In some cases, that is their forte. But in many more the goal is to shake us out of the lethargy of youth. In these instances, it is much more about growing up to become a multi-faceted human being.
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

The Real One Per-Centers

Not long ago I gave a talk to some Tea Party folks. I was explaining why I think liberalism is destined for the ash heap of history. In making my case, among the things I asserted is that we humans are a hierarchical species. Always and everywhere, we rank ourselves in comparison with others.
Rick Santorum is not my choice in presidential material, but he was correct in also insisting that complete equality is not a good idea. Not only do people differ in their abilities, but also in their achievements.
The way I put it to the Tea Party is that while equality of opportunity is worth pursuing, an equality of results is unlikely. Furthermore, I do not want resources equally distributed. To the contrary, I believe people should get what they earn.
Given that I was addressing conservatives, there was wide agreement with this sentiment. My listeners also believed in personal responsibility and individual effort. Like many not blinded by liberal ideals, they understood that we owe a debt of gratitude to those who perform above the norm.
This insight has become more important with the demonization of the so-called “one per-centers.” Thanks to the Democratic decision to resort to class-warfare, the very rich have been portrayed as lazy parasites.
The image Barack Obama presents when bemoaning the refusal of the wealthy to “pay their fair share” is of smug self-entitlement. But is this the true picture? Are those at the top of the social pyramid self-satisfied plutocrats who are sucking the life-blood from the rest of us?
Well, let’s see. To this end, I consulted Forbes list of the 400 hundred richest Americans. Topping the list, with a net worth of over sixty billion dollars, is Bill Gates. What a surprise, the creative force behind Microsoft is still riding high. Just behind him is that habitual number two: Warren Buffet. The guru of Berkshire Hathaway has fallen to around forty billion, but the stock market has recently hit a few speed bumps.
After this comes Lawrence Ellison of Oracle and then several members of the Walton family. Sam’s kids are making out just fine from the proceeds of Wal-Mart. Nonetheless, the mayor of New York City is hard on their heels. Michael Bloomberg, the creator the Bloomberg news empire, is evidently unwilling to sit back and clip coupons.
Next come the Koch brothers. As Obama’s latest whipping boys, these manufacturing titans are certainly rich. Each approaches the twenty billion range. After this are the masterminds behind Google. Sergey Brin and Larry Paige are only worth about fifteen billion, but then Google is the new kid on the block
Steven Balmer and Paul Allen, who rode to the top on the Microsoft gravy train, are doing okay, if worth only slightly more than ten billion. But who is that sitting right up there in the same neighborhood? Why it is that liberal billionaire investor: George Soros. I guess he should be ashamed of the company he is keeping.
Oh yes, Michael Dell of Dell Computers is right there too with his fifteen billion. One more of these wealthy college dropouts, he did better than Steve Jobs who made the mistake of selling his Apple stock before the company rocketed to a net worth of half a trillion dollars.
What do these folks have in common? Except for the Walton’s, they all made their own fortunes. Even in their case, however, the company providing their wealth is of recent origin.
So where are the Rockefeller’s, Vanderbilt’s, Astor’s, and Kennedy’s? The only conclusion one can reach is that the one per-center’s are not what they once were. Almost all of today’s billionaires have earned their own fortunes.
Does this make them parasites? Have they hurt us in the process of getting wealthy? Or have we too benefited from their efforts?
You be the judge.
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University

Saturday, March 17, 2012

Shades of John F. Kennedy

Many commentators have noted the affinity evangelicals have for Rick Santorum. They have voted for him in large numbers because they apparently feel comfortable with his sincere piety. Although he is a Catholic, his biblical principles resonate with them on a gut level.
What the analysts have also noticed is that Santorum supporters are concentrated in agricultural areas. Although Rick regularly alludes to his coal miner roots, it is rural evangelicals who form the core of his support. Meanwhile, these same folks have been averse to Mitt Romney.
My first reaction was that this did not make much sense. Romney, after all, is a transparently moral person whose value system parallels that of evangelicals. Why wouldn’t they recognize this connection and reward it?
My wife provided what I think is the key. She was raised as an evangelical in rural Ohio. In fact, Santorum carried the county in which her parents have their farm.
According to Linda, she met no Jews in growing up. The few she knew about were doctors and lawyers. Nonetheless, they were not the ordinary folks with whom one regularly rubbed shoulders. As such, they were exotic. In other words, it was difficult for her neighbors to identify with them
This put me in mind of the fact that there are few Mormons in rural evangelical areas. As a consequence, they too would seem exotic. While the doctrines of the Mormon Church may strike many Christians as strange, it is probably more important that they have little contact with real live Mormons.
Then I made the connection with John F. Kennedy. When he ran for president, he too had difficulty with rural evangelicals. As Santorum himself reminded us, JFK had to go out of his way to assure these folks that he was an American before he was a Catholic. He essentially told them he could be trusted because he was one of them.
Even so, Kennedy had to select Lyndon Johnson as his running mate. Kennedy did not like Johnson, but he knew that without LBJ’s southern constituents, he was unlikely to be elected. Indeed, this strategy worked. In what turned out to be a very close election, these people made the difference.
To return to Romney, he too makes rural evangelicals feel uncomfortable. Its not just that he is rich and urban. Because his background is so different from their own, they wonder how he will govern. What, they ask themselves, does he really believe? Yet no matter how fervent his assurances, they cannot help but feel uneasy.
Here in Georgia the rural/urban split was once again on display. As was the case in South Carolina, Florida, Michigan, and Ohio, urbanites heavily favored Romney. Actually, they did so in Cobb County. Despite the fact that there are many evangelicals in the Atlanta suburbs, as city dwellers they are comfortable with cultural disparities.
What explains the electoral discrepancy is thus rural isolation, not religion. But times change. As people gain exposure to outsiders, these aliens are transformed into normal human beings.
This is what happened to Catholics. Were once they were foreign to the rural South, today they are a familiar part of the landscape. As a result, rural evangelicals are not frightened by their differences. This is why so many have been able to embrace Santorum with nary a qualm. He is now one of them.
The same transformation is apt to occur with respect to Romney—assuming he is elected president. When people see him day-to-day behaving in ways they find beneficial, he too will be viewed as ordinary and safe. Once this happens, we as a nation will have taken another stride forward.
In the meantime, we are embarked on a learning curve. And make no mistake about it; if Romney gets the Republican nomination, rural evangelicals will vote for him in overwhelming numbers.
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University