The snowdrifts are piling up. Even though it has been a hot summer, we are being buried under tons of verbal snow. If you don’t yet get my drift, I am referring to the endless political snow jobs to which we have been treated. Were these actually cooling, they might be welcome, but, alas, they are not.
We have been warned early and often that this year’s presidential campaign would be the dirtiest in memory and it is living up to this prediction. Many commentators have cautioned that with a president who cannot afford to run on his record, he would probably resort to tearing down his opponent.
To add to this, many of them forecast that the accusations leveled against Romney would be false. Actually, they held that many would be lies. It is very unusual for a sitting president to be called a liar so often and regarding so many different matters, but Barack Obama has earned this distinction.
Yes, Democrats complained that “Bush lied and people died,” but this was about a single issue. And yes, Bob Dole found his reputation tarnished when he complained that a rival had lied about him, but Dole was already perceived as mean-spirited.
With Obama it is a little different. At first, his critics were gentle. They did not want to attack our first Black president; hence they suggested he was being “misleading.” Yet eventually the misrepresentations flew so thick and heavy that he was accused not only of lying, but of being a demagogue.
Recently he, and/or his people, have asserted that Romney may be a felon, that he is certainly a vulture capitalist who exported jobs over seas, and that he cares only about the rich—not women, minorities or the poor. According to them, he is a heartless fiend who is clearly not presidential material.
Mitt was a little slow in rebutting these charges so some liberals took comfort that their strategy was working. They would not have to defend the economy or Obamacare because the public’s attention would be elsewhere. As a result, their man’s inherent goodness would carry him through.
To me, this looks like denial. Committed liberals, who naturally want their favorite to win, have apparently convinced themselves he will. This does not surprise me. What does is the large numbers of voters who have not yet caught on to how disingenuous the president and his supporters are.
Recently I have been reading Erik Larson’s In the Garden of the Beasts. It is the story of Adolf Hitler’s first year in office as seen through the eyes of the American ambassador and his family. It is also a story of willful self-deception.
Hitler was a depraved leader from day one. His oppression of the German people, and especially of the Jews, began very soon after he took office. Except many people refused to believe it. The saw the clean streets and the orderly citizens and concluded what they wanted to conclude, namely that Hitler was rescuing his country from the Depression.
They also believed Hitler when he affirmed his desire for peace. Americans did not want war; Germans did not want war; surely Hitler did not want it either. He could not be so mad as to imagine that military adventurism would succeed.
Mind you, all people had to do was travel a few miles out of Berlin to observe the feverish preparations for war. Factories were being revved up to produce arms and military camps were sprouting along the highways. The evidence was there to see, but only for those prepared to see it.
Hitler was playing for time so that he could build his army, navy and air corps. In this, he did very well. Now Barack Obama is also playing for time. If he can keep people from asking embarrassing questions, he just might sneak over the electoral finish line. After that the deluge—but neither he nor his supporters care about that.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Saturday, August 4, 2012
Sunday, July 29, 2012
Responsibility versus Irresponsibility
Reading about the childhoods of Barack Obama and Mitt Romney is an excursion into stark opposites. The places they fit in their families of origin were so different that it would be a miracle if they turned out to deal with life the same way.
And, of course, they did not. Romney was deeply loved by parents who were always there for him. Besides the financial advantages he received, his was a secure upbringing. There were never any doubts that if he ran into trouble both his mother and father would be there to help out.
Obama, in contrast, was the next best thing to an orphan. Not only did his biological father abandon him when he was a month old, but his mother did almost the same several years later—leaving him to be raised by maternal grandparents.
As might be supposed, Barack resented this neglect. But mindful of his need not to alienate people who might abandon him, he kept a diplomatic silence. Only rarely did he express his bitterness at being what he described as “a supporting player” in the drama of his mother’s life.
Naturally, these disparities influenced the approach these two men took to life. Mitt became an extremely responsible person. Frequently volunteering to take on important tasks, he dedicated himself to fulfilling his obligations—which he habitually did with grace.
Whether this was guarding the symbol of the Stanford football team from their rivals at Berkley during his freshman year at college or taking over leadership of his Mormon mission in France when the official leader was injured in an automobile accident, he got the job done and done well.
This attitude later extended to his graduate studies, his wife and children, employment as a mid-level executive at Bain and Co., founder of Bain Capital, saving the winter Olympics, and governing the state of Massachusetts. In no case did he shirk his responsibilities.
Barack’s life course has been diametrically different. It is a study in temporary attachments and an unwillingness to make lasting commitments. Having been left behind by the people upon whom he should have been able to depend, he has subsequently become proficient in leaving others.
Like Mitt, Obama went to several colleges, but unlike Mitt he never took accountable positions at any of these. Instead he was an observer, whose energies turned inward. Next he abandoned several girlfriends, opted out of an editorial post he loathed, and took a community-organizing job he knew would be temporary.
When Barack finally did commit to Chicago, each step he took was calculated to advance his political career. The responsibilities he accepted (with the probable exception of his children) were essentially in service to what he desired, not what others needed.
This same attitude has been on display in politics. This, after all, was a man who specialized in voting “present” when he was in the Illinois legislature. There were to be no fingerprints on measures that might later get him in trouble. Then, after he made it to the U.S. senate, he assiduously avoided legislative initiatives.
Once he became president, the pattern continued. Thus, he farmed out his stimulus bill, Obamacare, and Dodd/Frank to be cobbled together by others. Nor did he put forward a budget that addressed the deficit or entitlements. He would not be responsible for unexpected bumps along the way.
By now observers, whose eyes are open, are aware that our president is a man of many excuses. According to him, it is always someone else’s fault when things go wrong; never his. The responsibility belongs to Bush, the Japanese Tsunami, the European financial crisis, Republican obstructionism, etc. etc. etc.
If the past means anything, if people tend to repeat long established precedents, we can be confident about what the future holds for each man. One will surely continue to be responsible and the other irresponsible. Only it is now up to us to choose between them.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
And, of course, they did not. Romney was deeply loved by parents who were always there for him. Besides the financial advantages he received, his was a secure upbringing. There were never any doubts that if he ran into trouble both his mother and father would be there to help out.
Obama, in contrast, was the next best thing to an orphan. Not only did his biological father abandon him when he was a month old, but his mother did almost the same several years later—leaving him to be raised by maternal grandparents.
As might be supposed, Barack resented this neglect. But mindful of his need not to alienate people who might abandon him, he kept a diplomatic silence. Only rarely did he express his bitterness at being what he described as “a supporting player” in the drama of his mother’s life.
Naturally, these disparities influenced the approach these two men took to life. Mitt became an extremely responsible person. Frequently volunteering to take on important tasks, he dedicated himself to fulfilling his obligations—which he habitually did with grace.
Whether this was guarding the symbol of the Stanford football team from their rivals at Berkley during his freshman year at college or taking over leadership of his Mormon mission in France when the official leader was injured in an automobile accident, he got the job done and done well.
This attitude later extended to his graduate studies, his wife and children, employment as a mid-level executive at Bain and Co., founder of Bain Capital, saving the winter Olympics, and governing the state of Massachusetts. In no case did he shirk his responsibilities.
Barack’s life course has been diametrically different. It is a study in temporary attachments and an unwillingness to make lasting commitments. Having been left behind by the people upon whom he should have been able to depend, he has subsequently become proficient in leaving others.
Like Mitt, Obama went to several colleges, but unlike Mitt he never took accountable positions at any of these. Instead he was an observer, whose energies turned inward. Next he abandoned several girlfriends, opted out of an editorial post he loathed, and took a community-organizing job he knew would be temporary.
When Barack finally did commit to Chicago, each step he took was calculated to advance his political career. The responsibilities he accepted (with the probable exception of his children) were essentially in service to what he desired, not what others needed.
This same attitude has been on display in politics. This, after all, was a man who specialized in voting “present” when he was in the Illinois legislature. There were to be no fingerprints on measures that might later get him in trouble. Then, after he made it to the U.S. senate, he assiduously avoided legislative initiatives.
Once he became president, the pattern continued. Thus, he farmed out his stimulus bill, Obamacare, and Dodd/Frank to be cobbled together by others. Nor did he put forward a budget that addressed the deficit or entitlements. He would not be responsible for unexpected bumps along the way.
By now observers, whose eyes are open, are aware that our president is a man of many excuses. According to him, it is always someone else’s fault when things go wrong; never his. The responsibility belongs to Bush, the Japanese Tsunami, the European financial crisis, Republican obstructionism, etc. etc. etc.
If the past means anything, if people tend to repeat long established precedents, we can be confident about what the future holds for each man. One will surely continue to be responsible and the other irresponsible. Only it is now up to us to choose between them.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
A Tale of Two Fathers
As a sociologist, I learned many lessons about families from David Popenoe. One of the most important concerns the role of fathers. He helped me realize that fathers can make a huge difference in the lives of their children. Mothers matte, but fathers are far from irrelevant.
Nowadays with two out of every five children born out of wedlock and most of these raised by single mothers, this fact has become of crucial significance. What recently drove this home for me was reading two biographies, one of Barack Obama and the other of Mitt Romney.
David Maraniss’ book Barack Obama: the Story and Michael Kranish and Scott Helman’s The Real Romney could scarcely have depicted more different childhoods and more different parents. At the end, I was left with no doubt about why these men have grown into such different adults.
Let us begin with Obama’s father. By now almost everyone has heard that Barack senior was Kenyan and by all accounts intellectually gifted. Far fewer are aware of how emotionally damaged the man was. Expected by many to become an important personage, he never achieved this status; largely because of his imperfections.
If we start with his son’s arrival in the world, Barack senior’s story includes marrying the future president’s mother, but he was little more than a sperm donor. After not telling Stanley Ann Dunham that he already had a wife and children in Kenya, he managed to live with her for but one month after the birth of their son.
In no sense was he ever paternal. Yes, he ran away from Hawaii to go to school in Harvard, but this pattern of running away existed before, and after, Barack II’s arrival. In some ways this was lucky for his American son because when he did stay with his wives (there were several), he frequently beat them.
On top of this Obama senior was a raging alcoholic with a penchant for getting into fatal automobile accidents. The one that eventually took his own life was but one of a series that never induced him to become more careful. Arrogant and overbearing, he was going to do things his way.
Mitt Romney, on the other hand, had a father who was present and supportive. George Romney was a self made man and a dedicated family man. Having dropped out of college to marry his wife, they remained married and available to their children.
George was a hard driving executive who rose to become the CEO of American Motors and a three-time governor of Michigan. Nonetheless, he always made time for his children; especially the youngest one Mitt. Furthermore, he listened to what his son said and respected his contributions.
George also encouraged Mitt to live up to his potential. Besides financial support, he supplied something even more valuable; he bequeathed his son a strong sense of self. Right from the beginning the young Mitt emulated his father’s sense of responsibility and leadership.
Young Barack, in contrast, was left adrift. Often uncertain about who he was or where he belonged, his early life featured unfocused explorations. The wonder is that he found an identity he could sustain.
Obama wrote a book entitled Dreams from My Father, but in truth he obtained almost nothing from his father except perhaps his intelligence and a hole in his soul. He had to learn how to be a man with very little guidance from a successful and committed adult male.
Barack junior today presents an appearance of preternatural stability. Nothing seems to faze him. But this is analogous to what has been called precocious independence. Children who lack dependable attachment figures frequently develop a façade of self-sufficiency. This does not, however, signal an absence of inner turmoil.
For Mitt, however, the inner stability is real and presidential. It is a precious legacy given to him by a father who was reliably there.
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Nowadays with two out of every five children born out of wedlock and most of these raised by single mothers, this fact has become of crucial significance. What recently drove this home for me was reading two biographies, one of Barack Obama and the other of Mitt Romney.
David Maraniss’ book Barack Obama: the Story and Michael Kranish and Scott Helman’s The Real Romney could scarcely have depicted more different childhoods and more different parents. At the end, I was left with no doubt about why these men have grown into such different adults.
Let us begin with Obama’s father. By now almost everyone has heard that Barack senior was Kenyan and by all accounts intellectually gifted. Far fewer are aware of how emotionally damaged the man was. Expected by many to become an important personage, he never achieved this status; largely because of his imperfections.
If we start with his son’s arrival in the world, Barack senior’s story includes marrying the future president’s mother, but he was little more than a sperm donor. After not telling Stanley Ann Dunham that he already had a wife and children in Kenya, he managed to live with her for but one month after the birth of their son.
In no sense was he ever paternal. Yes, he ran away from Hawaii to go to school in Harvard, but this pattern of running away existed before, and after, Barack II’s arrival. In some ways this was lucky for his American son because when he did stay with his wives (there were several), he frequently beat them.
On top of this Obama senior was a raging alcoholic with a penchant for getting into fatal automobile accidents. The one that eventually took his own life was but one of a series that never induced him to become more careful. Arrogant and overbearing, he was going to do things his way.
Mitt Romney, on the other hand, had a father who was present and supportive. George Romney was a self made man and a dedicated family man. Having dropped out of college to marry his wife, they remained married and available to their children.
George was a hard driving executive who rose to become the CEO of American Motors and a three-time governor of Michigan. Nonetheless, he always made time for his children; especially the youngest one Mitt. Furthermore, he listened to what his son said and respected his contributions.
George also encouraged Mitt to live up to his potential. Besides financial support, he supplied something even more valuable; he bequeathed his son a strong sense of self. Right from the beginning the young Mitt emulated his father’s sense of responsibility and leadership.
Young Barack, in contrast, was left adrift. Often uncertain about who he was or where he belonged, his early life featured unfocused explorations. The wonder is that he found an identity he could sustain.
Obama wrote a book entitled Dreams from My Father, but in truth he obtained almost nothing from his father except perhaps his intelligence and a hole in his soul. He had to learn how to be a man with very little guidance from a successful and committed adult male.
Barack junior today presents an appearance of preternatural stability. Nothing seems to faze him. But this is analogous to what has been called precocious independence. Children who lack dependable attachment figures frequently develop a façade of self-sufficiency. This does not, however, signal an absence of inner turmoil.
For Mitt, however, the inner stability is real and presidential. It is a precious legacy given to him by a father who was reliably there.
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Sunday, July 15, 2012
Literary License
I have been writing that Barack Obama is a liar for several years now. There can be no doubt that he has an only passing acquaintance with the truth; nonetheless I have decided that I have not been sufficiently generous to our president.
David Maraniss’ book Barack Obama: The Story has led me to reevaluate the president’s motives and methods. As many others have noted, when he wrote his autobiography Dreams from My Father, Obama took many liberties. His account of the past, when investigated closely, does not jibe with reality.
For one thing, the characters he describes do not always match actual individuals. They are frequently composites intended to make an ideological point. For another, his sequencing is recurrently out of joint. Once more the objective is dramatic impact rather than historical accuracy.
At one point in Maraniss’ narrative, he describes the power that Obama imputes to words. Barack allegedly told classmates that words were more potent than economics or military might. Judging from the way he behaves in office, he still believes this.
Apparently Obama once thought he might become a writer. We may assume that this included writing novels. If it did, then he has succeeded in his ambition. His erstwhile autobiography turns out to be more like a novel—with himself as hero—than an honest rendering of his early life.
Having invented himself as the kind of person he wanted to be, he had no difficulty resorting to literary license to persuade his readers that this is who he is—and that the way he depicts the world is a correct portrayal of it.
For Obama fantasy mixes with reality in a way that he may have trouble telling apart. One thing Maraniss makes perfectly clear: Barack did not have a storybook childhood. Time and again, essentially emotionally abandoned, he had to develop the detached persona we have become familiar with in the White House.
We are also given to understand that Obama had to struggle with his racial identity. It was not merely that he was half white and half black, but that wherever he found himself, he was different. Always the outsider, whether in Hawaii, Indonesia, California or New York, he needed a reliable peg on which to hang his sense of self.
No wonder he manufactured this as a novelist would. No wonder too that it includes elements of the poseur. In need of persuading others—not just himself—that he was significant personage, he developed social gambits that projected himself as surreally heroic. Think of his pose with head thrust forward and chin pointed up—much in a manner of a Soviet hero-worker.
Think too of all of those public utterances that I have characterized as lies. They may not be so much lies as heroic epigrams. They are inspiring little dictums that sound good—and more importantly—make him look good. For him, what matters is their political effect, not their truth-value.
So Obama tells us he is pleased that the Supreme Court upheld ObamaCare. He reiterates that it will be good for the nation, but he does not mention that the court called his policy a “tax.” That would not sit well with the public, so it is not denied; merely left out.
Or he gives a speech in which he boasts of having reduced the deficit. He insists he has cut billions from the budget, but leaves out the trillions he added. He certainly cannot allude to the fact that the budget proposals he sent congress were roundly rejected; even by Democrats who realized they called for unsustainable spending.
What then are we to make of this president who is concerned more with guarding his damaged personhood than with protecting the nation he is sworn to defend? If we are decent people, we can feel sympathy for him. But if we care about the welfare of our country, we dare not re-elect him.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
David Maraniss’ book Barack Obama: The Story has led me to reevaluate the president’s motives and methods. As many others have noted, when he wrote his autobiography Dreams from My Father, Obama took many liberties. His account of the past, when investigated closely, does not jibe with reality.
For one thing, the characters he describes do not always match actual individuals. They are frequently composites intended to make an ideological point. For another, his sequencing is recurrently out of joint. Once more the objective is dramatic impact rather than historical accuracy.
At one point in Maraniss’ narrative, he describes the power that Obama imputes to words. Barack allegedly told classmates that words were more potent than economics or military might. Judging from the way he behaves in office, he still believes this.
Apparently Obama once thought he might become a writer. We may assume that this included writing novels. If it did, then he has succeeded in his ambition. His erstwhile autobiography turns out to be more like a novel—with himself as hero—than an honest rendering of his early life.
Having invented himself as the kind of person he wanted to be, he had no difficulty resorting to literary license to persuade his readers that this is who he is—and that the way he depicts the world is a correct portrayal of it.
For Obama fantasy mixes with reality in a way that he may have trouble telling apart. One thing Maraniss makes perfectly clear: Barack did not have a storybook childhood. Time and again, essentially emotionally abandoned, he had to develop the detached persona we have become familiar with in the White House.
We are also given to understand that Obama had to struggle with his racial identity. It was not merely that he was half white and half black, but that wherever he found himself, he was different. Always the outsider, whether in Hawaii, Indonesia, California or New York, he needed a reliable peg on which to hang his sense of self.
No wonder he manufactured this as a novelist would. No wonder too that it includes elements of the poseur. In need of persuading others—not just himself—that he was significant personage, he developed social gambits that projected himself as surreally heroic. Think of his pose with head thrust forward and chin pointed up—much in a manner of a Soviet hero-worker.
Think too of all of those public utterances that I have characterized as lies. They may not be so much lies as heroic epigrams. They are inspiring little dictums that sound good—and more importantly—make him look good. For him, what matters is their political effect, not their truth-value.
So Obama tells us he is pleased that the Supreme Court upheld ObamaCare. He reiterates that it will be good for the nation, but he does not mention that the court called his policy a “tax.” That would not sit well with the public, so it is not denied; merely left out.
Or he gives a speech in which he boasts of having reduced the deficit. He insists he has cut billions from the budget, but leaves out the trillions he added. He certainly cannot allude to the fact that the budget proposals he sent congress were roundly rejected; even by Democrats who realized they called for unsustainable spending.
What then are we to make of this president who is concerned more with guarding his damaged personhood than with protecting the nation he is sworn to defend? If we are decent people, we can feel sympathy for him. But if we care about the welfare of our country, we dare not re-elect him.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Saturday, July 7, 2012
Liberal Arrogance
Just when I think that the egotism of liberals can grow no greater, it does. Who thought that Barack Obama would cross the line in the sand that he himself drew and unilaterally bypass Congress to mandate temporary amnesty for some illegals?
Likewise, who would have imagined that having berated George W. Bush for asserting executive privilege, he would do the same for the Fast and Furious scandal? Attorney General Eric Holder has been stonewalling congress for over a year, but why would the president have joined him in this intransigence?
And as for the mainstream media, I was appalled to learn how little attention they have paid to Fast and Furious. Two Americans die because of an ill-conceived effort to track arms into Mexico and the network television news only devotes seconds to covering the story? Is this Alice Through the Looking Glass?
Not long ago I discovered a clue to this mentality. I was reading a book called Red Families versus Blue Families by Nancy Cahn and June Carbone. As lawyers, the authors were analyzing the legal differences regarding sex and the marriage statues between liberal and conservative states.
For the most part, they did a credible job. But then I encountered their thumbnail descriptions of conservatives and liberals. Mind you, they labeled them as traditionalists and modernists respectively, but the intent was unmistakable.
According to the authors, conservatives adhere to traditions, respect authority, and desire order, whereas liberals are flexible thinkers, tolerate diversity and place a greater emphasis on equality. Guess which group they favor?
But think about how tendentious and arrogant this is. Clearly the conservatives are the rigid bad guys, whereas the liberals are the progressive good guys. One group is obviously mired in the past, while the other optimistically looks forward to a better future. (By the way, hasn’t Obama been touting his moving “forward.”)
Anyway, let’s start with this business of conservatives respecting authority, while liberals presumably do not. Has anybody read The New York Times lately? “Kneejerk liberal” is a hackneyed appellation, but it surely applies to the Times. So what of those readers for whom its authority is Biblical? Are they not slaves to authority?
And as to tolerance of diversity, how come the liberals have difficulty tolerating religious fundamentalists? They insist that they are non-judgmental and give everyone “unconditional positive regard;” that is, unless you are perceived as a political enemy. Then you are obviously stupid and unworthy of respect.
With regard to this business of liberals emphasizing equality (of results, not opportunity), why didn’t the authors note that conservatives emphasize freedom? Isn’t the pursuit of liberty a commendable quest? Indeed, I personally feel freedom is far more important than equality.
What liberals in their arrogance fail to realize is that a respect for tradition and a desire for progress are not incompatible. If anything, a commitment to the Constitution—an admittedly old document—may facilitate the preservation of the very freedoms that make democratic progress possible.
Being forward looking is not equivalent being in favor of a bigger and more centralized federal government, as liberals desire. Nor does it mean that you must put on blinders and fail to comprehend that very large budget deficits are a prescription for economic ruin.
In truth, it is the conservatives who are looking forward to warn of the dangers of concentrating power in fewer hands. Those old-fashioned traditions of theirs—you know the ones about a separation of political power—tell them that what Obama and company are attempting might just undermine our personal rights.
I may be simple-minded, but the way I see it: those who do not do not grasp this unadorned fact are not flexible thinkers. They are so sure they are “the best and brightest” that it never occurs to them that those who disagree might have a valid point or two.
Now that’s arrogance!
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Likewise, who would have imagined that having berated George W. Bush for asserting executive privilege, he would do the same for the Fast and Furious scandal? Attorney General Eric Holder has been stonewalling congress for over a year, but why would the president have joined him in this intransigence?
And as for the mainstream media, I was appalled to learn how little attention they have paid to Fast and Furious. Two Americans die because of an ill-conceived effort to track arms into Mexico and the network television news only devotes seconds to covering the story? Is this Alice Through the Looking Glass?
Not long ago I discovered a clue to this mentality. I was reading a book called Red Families versus Blue Families by Nancy Cahn and June Carbone. As lawyers, the authors were analyzing the legal differences regarding sex and the marriage statues between liberal and conservative states.
For the most part, they did a credible job. But then I encountered their thumbnail descriptions of conservatives and liberals. Mind you, they labeled them as traditionalists and modernists respectively, but the intent was unmistakable.
According to the authors, conservatives adhere to traditions, respect authority, and desire order, whereas liberals are flexible thinkers, tolerate diversity and place a greater emphasis on equality. Guess which group they favor?
But think about how tendentious and arrogant this is. Clearly the conservatives are the rigid bad guys, whereas the liberals are the progressive good guys. One group is obviously mired in the past, while the other optimistically looks forward to a better future. (By the way, hasn’t Obama been touting his moving “forward.”)
Anyway, let’s start with this business of conservatives respecting authority, while liberals presumably do not. Has anybody read The New York Times lately? “Kneejerk liberal” is a hackneyed appellation, but it surely applies to the Times. So what of those readers for whom its authority is Biblical? Are they not slaves to authority?
And as to tolerance of diversity, how come the liberals have difficulty tolerating religious fundamentalists? They insist that they are non-judgmental and give everyone “unconditional positive regard;” that is, unless you are perceived as a political enemy. Then you are obviously stupid and unworthy of respect.
With regard to this business of liberals emphasizing equality (of results, not opportunity), why didn’t the authors note that conservatives emphasize freedom? Isn’t the pursuit of liberty a commendable quest? Indeed, I personally feel freedom is far more important than equality.
What liberals in their arrogance fail to realize is that a respect for tradition and a desire for progress are not incompatible. If anything, a commitment to the Constitution—an admittedly old document—may facilitate the preservation of the very freedoms that make democratic progress possible.
Being forward looking is not equivalent being in favor of a bigger and more centralized federal government, as liberals desire. Nor does it mean that you must put on blinders and fail to comprehend that very large budget deficits are a prescription for economic ruin.
In truth, it is the conservatives who are looking forward to warn of the dangers of concentrating power in fewer hands. Those old-fashioned traditions of theirs—you know the ones about a separation of political power—tell them that what Obama and company are attempting might just undermine our personal rights.
I may be simple-minded, but the way I see it: those who do not do not grasp this unadorned fact are not flexible thinkers. They are so sure they are “the best and brightest” that it never occurs to them that those who disagree might have a valid point or two.
Now that’s arrogance!
Melvyn L. Fein. Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Saturday, June 30, 2012
The Imperial Presidency
After President Obama granted limited amnesty to illegal immigrants who had entered the United States before the age of sixteen, a few barbs about how this indicated the rise of an “Imperial Presidency” were directed his way.
What struck me, however, was just how few and muted these were. Not many commentators were prepared to give the accusation full voice. This was in marked contrast with how fervently George W. Bush, Ronald Reagan, and Richard Nixon endured similar charges.
An Imperial President presumably rules like a king. He does what he wants irrespective of congressional actions. When thwarted by legislators who prove resistant to such policies as the Dream Act, he implements them anyway. He does not allow our creaky democratic machinery to get in the way of what he considers best.
This is the very definition of what Obama did with respect to immigration. Instead of seeking relief for young illegals through legislation, he issued a decree directing the agencies under his command to enforce the rules—not as written—but as he wished they had been.
Of course, Barack warned us that he might do something of the sort about a year ago. He then told the nation that he would not allow obstructionist politicians to interfere with this plans. He would not wait for others to do what was right, but would do so on his own hook. Necessity could brook no delay.
So why isn’t the public outraged? Why aren’t people rushing to the barricades to defend the Constitution? Have ordinary citizens been anesthetized to presidential overreaching because there has been so much of it? What’s one more executive edict when so many have poured forth from environmental and labor agencies?
Maybe, however, the lack of indignation reflects the ho-hum attitude of Democrats and the mainstream media. Wasn’t it true that Nixon’s extra-legal initiatives become a scandal only after the media and moderate Republicans became concerned that he was breaking the law?
Nowadays the media are nearly silent no matter what the president does. Rather than make his look bad, they scarcely mention it when his government is sued for violating the Catholic Church’s first amendment rights. And as for the Democrats, they applaud his skill in putting Republicans on the defensive.
I have long since come to the conclusion that mainstream reporters and knee-jerk liberals have few principles. As long as their side triumphs, they have little concern about how this is achieved.
Yet the sad fact is that they may win this round. Barack may get to attract Hispanic voters via a transparently political ploy he blatantly describes as non-political. With crocodile tears in his eyes, he tells us this move is only fair, although last year he said it was beyond his powers.
Only what are Romney and the Republicans to do? If they oppose this policy too forcefully, it would be like kicking the Hispanics in the groin. Or if they go to the rooftops to scream that they aren’t going to tolerate such despotism any longer, they may appear as impotent as Peter Finch in the movie Network.
I am reminded of another Imperial Presidency—that of Andrew Jackson. Often parodied in the press as King Andrew, he frequently implemented policies of his own devising. His attitude was best reflected in a comment following a Supreme Court ruling he loathed.
After John Marshall and his colleagues ruled in Worcester v. Georgia that a Georgia law affecting the Cherokee Indians was unconstitutional, Jackson said “John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it.”
Barack Obama seems to have a similar attitude. Because almost nothing can be done between today and Election Day to neutralize his decision, he is daring his opponents to do anything. He assumes that if he wins reelection, he will be able to make his fiat stick, but if he doesn’t, it won’t matter because he will be gone.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
What struck me, however, was just how few and muted these were. Not many commentators were prepared to give the accusation full voice. This was in marked contrast with how fervently George W. Bush, Ronald Reagan, and Richard Nixon endured similar charges.
An Imperial President presumably rules like a king. He does what he wants irrespective of congressional actions. When thwarted by legislators who prove resistant to such policies as the Dream Act, he implements them anyway. He does not allow our creaky democratic machinery to get in the way of what he considers best.
This is the very definition of what Obama did with respect to immigration. Instead of seeking relief for young illegals through legislation, he issued a decree directing the agencies under his command to enforce the rules—not as written—but as he wished they had been.
Of course, Barack warned us that he might do something of the sort about a year ago. He then told the nation that he would not allow obstructionist politicians to interfere with this plans. He would not wait for others to do what was right, but would do so on his own hook. Necessity could brook no delay.
So why isn’t the public outraged? Why aren’t people rushing to the barricades to defend the Constitution? Have ordinary citizens been anesthetized to presidential overreaching because there has been so much of it? What’s one more executive edict when so many have poured forth from environmental and labor agencies?
Maybe, however, the lack of indignation reflects the ho-hum attitude of Democrats and the mainstream media. Wasn’t it true that Nixon’s extra-legal initiatives become a scandal only after the media and moderate Republicans became concerned that he was breaking the law?
Nowadays the media are nearly silent no matter what the president does. Rather than make his look bad, they scarcely mention it when his government is sued for violating the Catholic Church’s first amendment rights. And as for the Democrats, they applaud his skill in putting Republicans on the defensive.
I have long since come to the conclusion that mainstream reporters and knee-jerk liberals have few principles. As long as their side triumphs, they have little concern about how this is achieved.
Yet the sad fact is that they may win this round. Barack may get to attract Hispanic voters via a transparently political ploy he blatantly describes as non-political. With crocodile tears in his eyes, he tells us this move is only fair, although last year he said it was beyond his powers.
Only what are Romney and the Republicans to do? If they oppose this policy too forcefully, it would be like kicking the Hispanics in the groin. Or if they go to the rooftops to scream that they aren’t going to tolerate such despotism any longer, they may appear as impotent as Peter Finch in the movie Network.
I am reminded of another Imperial Presidency—that of Andrew Jackson. Often parodied in the press as King Andrew, he frequently implemented policies of his own devising. His attitude was best reflected in a comment following a Supreme Court ruling he loathed.
After John Marshall and his colleagues ruled in Worcester v. Georgia that a Georgia law affecting the Cherokee Indians was unconstitutional, Jackson said “John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it.”
Barack Obama seems to have a similar attitude. Because almost nothing can be done between today and Election Day to neutralize his decision, he is daring his opponents to do anything. He assumes that if he wins reelection, he will be able to make his fiat stick, but if he doesn’t, it won’t matter because he will be gone.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Saturday, June 23, 2012
All Politicians Lie?
“All politicians lie!”
By now I have heard this mantra thousands of times. Almost always it is issued for the mouths of liberal students trying to defend the latest deceit offered up by a liberal politician. Often nowadays, the person in question is the president of the United States—but his minions are also on the line.
The next thing I usually hear is that Bush lied too! Or that Republicans and/or conservatives are liars. If I suggest that not all politicians lie to the same degree, this may be acknowledged, but is treated as an incidental fact.
In contemplating how common this scenario is, several things strike me. The first is that these students, and the politicians whose example they are following, have become addicted to a strategy that most mothers warn against. They are essentially saying that: if everyone does it, it is okay.
Instead of defending a particular lie, they decide to accuse their opponents of the vice of which they stand accused. This shifts the focus of attention and when it works takes them off the hot seat. It may even succeed in establishing an equivalency between different instances of deception.
The way this often goes is: Well, Bush lied too! It doesn’t matter whether he actually lied or that he may have done so years ago, the current canard suddenly becomes unimportant. Now the fight is over whose lies are worse.
But that was not the original issue. The question was about this present lie and its implications. If the “everyone does it” ploy succeeds, then everyone is equally guilty and there is no current mendacity that should disqualify what liberals are arguing.
This seems to me a remarkably cynical gambit. Committed liberals appear to have become so jaded by the habitual deceits of their heroes that they no longer consider a lie wrong. Their criterion is now: Does it work? And if it does, then it is political wizardry.
We saw this recently when Democrats were accused of voter fraud in the Wisconsin recall election. Fraud is a kind of lying that, in this case, is utilized to change election results. Yet Wisconsin Democrats went on television, not to deny the fraud, but to assert that it was no big deal. After all everyone engages in fraud and it does not really alter the course of events.
Then there is the Department of Justice refusing to allow states like South Carolina to use picture ID’s for voters. This is said to protect equality, but what about protecting against dishonest manipulations. Evidently the fact that votes by felons, though illegal, probably allowed Al Franken to become a Minnesota senator does not matter.
There is also the spectacle of the President telling the nation that he has spent less than his predecessors. Given the fact that Obama increased the national debt by nearly six trillion dollars, this would seem to be a joke. But no, it was said with a straight face.
Barack’s defenders quickly rushed forward with a bogus accounting to demonstrate that black was white and white was black; an exercise that would have been unnecessary had the president been honest. Even so, many of his partisans swallowed this invention as if it were true.
Yes, everyone lies, especially if they are liberals. They have to because what they stand for is so egregiously fraudulent. Moreover, they are forced to defend their lies with another cordon of lies. They know that to do less would place their credibility in jeopardy.
But I submit that the credibility of people who have grown so comfortable with lying should be in jeopardy. The deceits emanating from Washington, be they about national security leaks or attacks on political opponents, have come so fast and furious, that they ought to be alarming to people who value honesty.
I have my fingers crossed that most Americans fall into the latter category.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
By now I have heard this mantra thousands of times. Almost always it is issued for the mouths of liberal students trying to defend the latest deceit offered up by a liberal politician. Often nowadays, the person in question is the president of the United States—but his minions are also on the line.
The next thing I usually hear is that Bush lied too! Or that Republicans and/or conservatives are liars. If I suggest that not all politicians lie to the same degree, this may be acknowledged, but is treated as an incidental fact.
In contemplating how common this scenario is, several things strike me. The first is that these students, and the politicians whose example they are following, have become addicted to a strategy that most mothers warn against. They are essentially saying that: if everyone does it, it is okay.
Instead of defending a particular lie, they decide to accuse their opponents of the vice of which they stand accused. This shifts the focus of attention and when it works takes them off the hot seat. It may even succeed in establishing an equivalency between different instances of deception.
The way this often goes is: Well, Bush lied too! It doesn’t matter whether he actually lied or that he may have done so years ago, the current canard suddenly becomes unimportant. Now the fight is over whose lies are worse.
But that was not the original issue. The question was about this present lie and its implications. If the “everyone does it” ploy succeeds, then everyone is equally guilty and there is no current mendacity that should disqualify what liberals are arguing.
This seems to me a remarkably cynical gambit. Committed liberals appear to have become so jaded by the habitual deceits of their heroes that they no longer consider a lie wrong. Their criterion is now: Does it work? And if it does, then it is political wizardry.
We saw this recently when Democrats were accused of voter fraud in the Wisconsin recall election. Fraud is a kind of lying that, in this case, is utilized to change election results. Yet Wisconsin Democrats went on television, not to deny the fraud, but to assert that it was no big deal. After all everyone engages in fraud and it does not really alter the course of events.
Then there is the Department of Justice refusing to allow states like South Carolina to use picture ID’s for voters. This is said to protect equality, but what about protecting against dishonest manipulations. Evidently the fact that votes by felons, though illegal, probably allowed Al Franken to become a Minnesota senator does not matter.
There is also the spectacle of the President telling the nation that he has spent less than his predecessors. Given the fact that Obama increased the national debt by nearly six trillion dollars, this would seem to be a joke. But no, it was said with a straight face.
Barack’s defenders quickly rushed forward with a bogus accounting to demonstrate that black was white and white was black; an exercise that would have been unnecessary had the president been honest. Even so, many of his partisans swallowed this invention as if it were true.
Yes, everyone lies, especially if they are liberals. They have to because what they stand for is so egregiously fraudulent. Moreover, they are forced to defend their lies with another cordon of lies. They know that to do less would place their credibility in jeopardy.
But I submit that the credibility of people who have grown so comfortable with lying should be in jeopardy. The deceits emanating from Washington, be they about national security leaks or attacks on political opponents, have come so fast and furious, that they ought to be alarming to people who value honesty.
I have my fingers crossed that most Americans fall into the latter category.
Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology
Kennesaw State University
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)